Forklift Hire vs Buy vs Lease: Which Is Right for Your Business?

When your business needs a forklift, the first big question is not which truck to choose — it is how to acquire it. Hiring, buying outright, and leasing all have genuine advantages depending on your situation. This guide breaks down each option clearly so you can make an informed decision.

Buying a forklift outright

Purchasing a forklift — new or used — means it immediately becomes a business asset. You own it, you can use it however you need, and you have no ongoing hire or lease payments once it is paid for.

Advantages of buying

  • No ongoing monthly payments once purchased
  • Asset sits on your balance sheet
  • Full flexibility — modify, resell, or continue using as required
  • Eligible for capital allowances on your tax return
  • Good value for long-term, high-usage operations

Disadvantages of buying

  • High upfront capital cost
  • You bear all maintenance and repair costs
  • Equipment depreciates — you carry the residual value risk
  • Upgrading requires selling the old unit, which takes time

Best suited for

Businesses with consistent, long-term forklift needs, sufficient capital, and in-house maintenance capacity.

Hiring a forklift

Short-term or contract hire means renting a forklift for a defined period — from a single day to several months. You return the truck when you no longer need it.

Advantages of hiring

  • Low upfront cost — just the first hire payment
  • Flexibility to scale up or down quickly
  • Maintenance and servicing is often included in the hire agreement
  • No long-term commitment — ideal for seasonal demand or project work
  • Access to up-to-date equipment without capital investment

Disadvantages of hiring

  • Higher cost per week or month compared to ownership over the long term
  • No asset on the balance sheet
  • Terms may restrict certain uses or operating environments

Best suited for

Businesses with variable or seasonal demand, short-term project requirements, or those who want to avoid capital expenditure.

Leasing a forklift (lease purchase or lease rental)

Leasing sits between buying and hiring. You make regular monthly payments over a fixed term — typically two to five years — either with the option to purchase at the end (lease purchase) or simply return the equipment (lease rental).

Advantages of leasing

  • Spreads the cost over time — manageable monthly payments
  • Preserves working capital for other business needs
  • Lease purchase allows eventual ownership
  • Lease rental payments are often fully tax-deductible
  • Easier to upgrade to newer equipment at end of term

Disadvantages of leasing

  • Commitment to a fixed term — early exit can incur penalties
  • Total cost over the lease term is higher than buying outright
  • Finance approval required

Best suited for

Businesses that want to spread the cost of a reliable, well-specified machine without a large upfront payment, and are confident in their medium-term requirements.

Quick comparison

Buy Hire Lease
Upfront cost High Low Low–Medium
Monthly cost None High Medium
Flexibility Low High Medium
Ownership Yes No Optional
Maintenance included No Often Sometimes
Best for Long-term use Short-term/variable Medium-term planned use

 

Talk to Davison Forklift about your options

At Davison Forklift, we offer forklift sales (new and used), short-term and contract hire, lease purchase, and lease rental — so we can genuinely help you choose the right approach for your business rather than pushing you towards one option. Call us on 01952 915 060 for an honest conversation.

CONTACT US