Electric vs Diesel vs LPG Forklifts: Pros, Cons & Costs

Choosing between electric, diesel, and LPG forklifts is one of the most consequential decisions when specifying materials handling equipment. Each type has genuine strengths — and real limitations. Here is an honest comparison to help you make the right choice for your operation.

Electric forklifts

Electric forklifts are powered by a lead-acid or lithium-ion battery. They are the most common choice for indoor operations across warehousing, manufacturing, and distribution.

Advantages

  • Zero tailpipe emissions — suitable for enclosed spaces and food environments
  • Lower running costs — electricity is cheaper than diesel or LPG per hour of operation
  • Quieter in operation — better for noise-sensitive environments
  • Lower maintenance costs — no engine, exhaust, or fuel system to service
  • Regenerative braking reduces wear on brake components

Disadvantages

  • Battery charging takes time — multi-shift operations may require spare batteries or opportunity charging
  • Higher upfront purchase cost (particularly lithium-ion)
  • Cold storage environments reduce battery performance and range
  • Less suited to outdoor or rough terrain work

Best for

Indoor warehousing, food and pharmaceutical environments, multi-shift operations with charging infrastructure, and businesses prioritising low running costs.

Diesel forklifts

Diesel forklifts are the traditional choice for outdoor and heavy-duty applications. They deliver high power, excellent load capacity, and are largely unaffected by weather conditions.

Advantages

  • High performance and lifting capacity — available up to 40+ tonnes
  • Suitable for outdoor use in all weather conditions
  • Quick refuelling — no downtime for charging
  • Robust in demanding environments

Disadvantages

  • Exhaust emissions — not suitable for enclosed spaces without ventilation
  • Higher running costs than electric
  • More complex engine maintenance
  • Noise levels higher than electric alternatives

Best for

Construction sites, outdoor yards, heavy manufacturing, dockside operations, and applications requiring high lift capacity.

LPG forklifts

LPG (liquefied petroleum gas) forklifts run on bottled gas and offer a middle ground between electric and diesel. They are suited to mixed indoor/outdoor environments where emissions need to be lower than diesel but versatility is important.

Advantages

  • Lower emissions than diesel — can be used indoors with adequate ventilation
  • Quick gas cylinder change — minimal downtime
  • Good performance across a range of temperatures
  • Suitable for mixed indoor/outdoor use

Disadvantages

  • Gas cylinder storage and handling requires compliance with safety regulations
  • Running costs higher than electric over time
  • Not zero-emission — not suitable for sealed food environments or sensitive indoor spaces

Best for

Mixed-use operations with both indoor and outdoor requirements, businesses transitioning away from diesel, and sites without electrical charging infrastructure.

Cost comparison summary

  Electric Diesel LPG
Purchase price Medium–High Medium Medium
Running cost/hr Low High Medium
Maintenance cost Low Medium–High Medium
Indoor use Yes With ventilation With ventilation
Outdoor use Limited Yes Yes
Refuel/recharge time Long (charge) Minutes Minutes

 

Discuss your requirements with Davison Forklift

We stock electric, diesel, and LPG forklifts for sale and hire, and our team will help you match the right truck to your specific environment and budget. Call 01952 915 060 or get in touch online.

CONTACT US